GameFly Offers Top Post-Prime Day Game Deals

Author: Isabella Oct 23,2025

GameFly is currently offering unbeatable discounts on PS5 and Xbox Series X titles along with Blu-ray movies. If you're hunting for major savings on recent blockbuster games, this sale is a must-see. Score incredible deals like Elden Ring Nightreign for just $27.99 and DOOM: The Dark Ages at $39.99 for PS5. These prices are hard to beat elsewhere anytime soon, especially post-Prime Day.

Note that all games are pre-owned (details below). Browse the full sale here or check out our top recommendations.

Enjoy Up to 50% Off Pre-Owned Games at GameFly

Elden Ring Nightreign offers a fresh take on From Software's signature formula, transforming the experience into a three-player co-op roguelite adventure. While it may appeal to selective tastes (see our review), the $27.99 price tag makes it far more enticing.

Though Xbox players may access DOOM: The Dark Ages via Game Pass, PS5 owners can grab this physical copy for substantially less than retail price. Don't miss our glowing 9/10 review.

The sale extends to Civilization VII, Monster Hunter Wilds, Assassin's Creed Shadows, and numerous Blu-rays including Mickey 17 and Mufasa: The Lion King—ample opportunities for savings.

Why GameFly Is Trusted for Pre-Owned Games

GameFly's "pre-played" inventory consists of titles previously rented to members but maintained in excellent condition—complete with original cases and inserts when available. Having personally purchased from their sales before, I couldn't distinguish these from brand-new copies except for missing shrink wrap.

Every purchase comes with a 100% satisfaction guarantee, ensuring refunds for any issues. Buying pre-owned here combines existing discounts with extra sale pricing—effectively doubling your savings on nearly-new games.